Skip to main content
DS05-140. 2004-122,1-3
Sugar dish
DS05-140. 2004-122,1-3

Sugar dish

Dateca. 1800
Maker d. 1817
MediumSilver
DimensionsOH: 7 3/8"; L (base): 4 1/4"
Credit LineMuseum Purchase, The Friends of Colonial Williamsburg Collections Fund
Object number2004-122,3A&B
DescriptionOval sugar dish on a stepped, oval foot with a concave rim, concave, domed lid with urn finial, and applied molded border around the rim.Label TextDescribing himself as a jeweler from London, Jeremiah Andrews moved several times during his long career. He worked in New York City from 1774 to1776, Philadelphia from 1776 to 1784, and spent a short period in Savannah, Georgia, before settling in Norfolk, Virginia, by 1791. There he pursued his trade until his death in 1817. Andrews’s products show influences from many of the places he worked. For example, the waste bowl in this tea service bears a pierced top gallery typical of those seen on Philadelphia silver forms.

The service is engraved “JES” for Captain John Stone and his wife, Elizabeth Keeling, residents of Princess Anne County, Virginia. It may have been made in association with their 1799 wedding.
Inscription(s)"JES" in feathered script for John Stone (d. 1821) and Elizabeth Keeling (1777-1843), married in 1799 in Norfolk, Virginia.Mark(s)"I·ANDREWS" and "NORFOLK" in relief wthin rectangles underneath the footProvenanceThis and its companion pieces descended in the Gatewood and related families of Norfolk and Hampton, Virginia.

Line of Descent through the Stone-Duncan-Gatewood Families:

The silver was probably bought after the marriage of Captain John Stone (d. 1821) and Elizabeth Keeling (1777-1843) in 1799, they lived in Norfolk, VA.

The silver went to daughter Virginia Stone (1813-1893), who married James Fox Duncan (1810-1835) in 1835.

Then the silver was left to daughter Harriet Elizabeth Duncan (1834-1913), who married Rev. Robert Gatewood (1829-1909) in 1854. They lived in Norfolk, VA.

Then it went to son William Gatewood (1869-1946) who married Mary Edwin Hartzel (1868-1951) in 1894. They lived in Newport News, VA.

The silver was left to daughter Harriet Virginia Gatewood (1900-1980) who married William James Sibley (1897-1955) in 1928. They lived in Hampton, VA.

Finally, the silver went to daughter Mary Anderton Sibley (b. 1937) who married Richard Arthur Manning (b. 1934) on 1994. They lived in Charleston, SC.
D2014-CMD. Teapot 2004-122,1
Jeremiah Andrews
ca. 1800
D2013-CMD. Coffeepot
Jeremiah Andrews
1792-1797
DS05-140. 2004-122,1-3
Jeremiah Andrews
ca. 1800
D2014-CMD. Waste bowl 2004-123
Jeremiah Andrews
ca. 1800
1988-475,2, Sugar Dish
William G. Forbes
1790-1805
Williams & Victor Teaset 2016-168
Jehu Williams (1788-1859) and John Victor (1793-1845) (Williams & Victor)
ca. 1835
D2013-CMD. Sugar dish
Thomas McCowat
1825-1840
2020-249,4a&b, Sugar Dish
Littleton Holland
ca. 1800
D2013-CMD. Creamer and sugar: 2012-177,1-2
Bailey & Co.
1835-1845
2021-35,A&B, Sugar Dish; Sugar Urn
Thibault
ca. 1825
D2010-CMD-022. Sugar urn.
Paul Revere Jr.
ca. 1795